“You can’t help getting older, but you don’t have to get old.” – George Burns
5/10
review written by Andrei Sipos on the 6th of June 2011
With the original
Pirates of the Caribbean trilogy having come to an end, it seems that Walt Disney is not yet ready to let go of the rum, thus making way for a fourth instalment in the franchise.
Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides is its name, both its title and plot inspired by
Tim Powers’ 1987 fantasy novel of the same name. However, there are a few noteworthy changes in this newest episode that sets it apart from all the other films in the series. First of all, Will Turner and Elizabeth Swann, the lovebirds that served as the main characters in the concluded trilogy are now gone. The newly established storyline also has little to do with the one in the other films of the series, spare for a few recurring characters.
With the previous instalments’ lead actors Orlando Bloom and Keira Knightley out of the picture, it is now up to
Johnny Depp as the beloved Jack Sparrow to carry
Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides as the film’s protagonist. Things start off with a few introductory action sequences constituting the recently detained Jack Sparrow’s intricate escape from the hands of authority, followed by a fair bit of exposition and yet another brief cameo appearance from
Keith Richards, as per the preceding chapter’s originating custom. After all is said and done, we have our beloved Captain Jack teaming up—much against his will—with the feisty Angelica, a former flame of his, and her apparent father, the notorious pirate Blackbeard, to set sail in search for the legendary Fountain of Youth.
However, on the chase for the waters said to restore youth are also the British Navy, led by a Captain Barbossa newly gone straight, and the nosy Spaniards. This is where
Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides commits a great fault: its plot is too complex for its own good, often deviating from the mean line of course and ending up dividing its time in order to develop several small subplots. That may have worked well had the movie been smart about it, but in this case it just seems to complicate matters for the sake of complicating matters, which doesn’t really make any sense because the films of this franchise have never been about elaborate plotlines, except maybe for
Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s End, and it didn’t serve that one well, either.
Of course, in order to benefit from the Fountain’s powers, one must perform a ritual involving two silver chalices, a mermaid’s tear, and whatever else can be found to extend the film’s running time to a respectable amount when in comparison with the rest of the
Pirates of the Caribbean movies. Director
Rob Marshall (famous for
Memoirs of a Geisha and the musicals
Chicago and
Nine), on board with the series for the first time, may or may not be among the ones to blame for some of the film’s shortcomings. Certain is, though, that the departure of Gore Verbinski, director of the series’ previous instalments, has left a void that
Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides failed to cover completely.
What makes
Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides walk the plank, though? The script is arguably the greatest contributing factor in that respect, turning out to be inexcusably weak for a film of this calibre. The plot is muddled and unnecessarily convoluted, the characters fail to make an impression comparable to that of the earlier movies, the humour is often forced—nearing excess—and seldom does it invoke any real laughs, and the journey is ultimately less greater in scope than the anterior adventures.
The
Pirates of the Caribbean films have never taken things too seriously, always opting for a more easy-going attitude that is characteristic of many other Walt Disney productions, but
Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides has definitely taken things a little too far. It’s less serious than the other films in the series—if that were even possible—and the amount of gravity around the story has also been reduced by a few notches. Much of this is due to the lack of any real protagonist and a grossly decreased number of ‘good guys.’ The character of Jack Sparrow, who has served as the series’ main attraction ever since its inception, doesn’t really work in the main role mostly because his intentions never tend towards being of an intentionally good nature—thus limiting his capabilities in the role of the protagonist—and also because he is the one providing comic relief in most scenes.

The deficiency of chiefly positive characters is also a significant reason why the film fails to be as engaging as it should. During most of the battles and action scenes, there really isn’t anyone to root for (except maybe Jack Sparrow, but he rarely faces any sort danger whatsoever), what with most of the characters acting either as villains, anti-heroes or being of the more self-centred variety. This creates a large gap in the story and ultimately impairs
Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides when it comes to its cinematic power.
By this point, claims of Johnny Depp’s act getting old will certainly arise. The truth is that his performance as the crafty and eccentric Captain Jack Sparrow is as good here as it ever was. The problem lies with the character itself, who, paired with the lazy writing plaguing this sequel and the sudden evolution from scene-stealing side character to full-fledged protagonist, is slowly (but surely, if things go on like this)nearing a point where he’s turned into a caricature of himself. Same goes for Barbossa (played wonderfully by
Geoffrey Rush yet again), minus Jack’s character change.
The two biggest additions to the cast are
Penelope Cruz and
Ian McShane playing Angelica and Blackbeard respectively. Angelica serves as an obvious romantic interest for Jack Sparrow, though their relationship doesn’t really advance beyond a few suggestive looks and a couple of heated lines of dialogue. Penelope Cruz seemed to done a decent enough job, though there was never room for any real development from her part, seeing as how Angelica stood in the shadow of her father for the most part of the film. Ian McShane’s performance was subtle and menacing, though his character not so much. As a villain, Blackbeard is neither as immoral as Barbossa, nor does he pose as much of a threat as Davy Jones did. He mostly just lurks around, committing a few petty acts of evil here and there, but not nearly enough to justify his stance as the main antagonist in the film.
For a $200 million budget movie (more or less) taking place on some of the most exotic places on Earth and dealing with swashbuckling tales of piracy and adventure,
Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides offers surprisingly few eye-popping moments, and the 3D doesn’t help much either. In terms of filmmaking, it seems as though the process has become quite tedious on all fronts: there’s less piracy to be had in this one, the action scenes aren’t as exciting anymore and the characters aren’t as magical as they once were.
Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides may be disguised by high production values, but beneath the surface it’s undoubtedly a waste of talent and effort. Some will be fooled, others not so much. As a sequel and supposed first piece of a new trilogy, it’s also a fine example of not knowing when to stop.